Independent estimate reviews · Roofing & exteriors
Know what’s missing before you sign.
A five-figure quote deserves more than a glance at the total. QuoteSift compares your home improvement estimates in plain English, so you can spot gaps and ask better questions.
Human-reviewed. Up to three estimates. No contractor sales pitch.
Clarity, not a sales pitch.
Look beyond the bottom line
Same roof.
Different promises.
The cheapest bid isn’t automatically the best value. Materials, quantities, exclusions and warranties can change what you’re actually buying.
A clear comparison. A better conversation.
You receive a written breakdown of differences, missing details and specific questions to take back to each contractor.
Bring the estimates together
Submit two or three roofing or exterior estimates for a manual, side-by-side review.
See what the totals don’t tell you
We compare stated materials, quantities, scope, exclusions and warranty terms—and flag what still needs clarification.
Ask before you commit
Use your written question list to clarify omissions and allowances. Add a walkthrough call if you’d like to talk through the comparison.
A small step before a big decision
Choose your level of clarity.
Start on your own, get a written review, or work through the details together.
The estimate checklist
Free
Start with these five checks before comparing totals.
- Are material types and product names specified?
- Are quantities and measurements included?
- What work is included—and excluded?
- How are unforeseen repairs priced?
- What do labor and material warranties cover?
Written clarity
Estimate comparison
$49
A manual written comparison of up to three estimates, with scope differences, missing details and questions to ask before signing.
Find a reviewTalk it through
Comparison + call
$149
Everything in the written comparison, plus a homeowner walkthrough call to discuss the findings and your next questions.
Find a walkthroughAvailable reviews
Our reviewer has a Proformance connection. We disclose relevant conflicts and do not review bids where the reviewer or their employer is competing. Reviews explain the submitted documents; they are not an on-site inspection or a guarantee of contractor performance.
Before the signature
Make the decision with your eyes open.
You don’t need to become a roofing expert. You need to know what’s included, what’s uncertain and what to ask next.
Compare my estimates